外国判决承认与执行视角下的正当法律程序探析
王克玉; 1:中央财经大学法学院 摘要(Abstract)：

一国司法判决寻求他国司法机关的承认和执行,除了有条约或互惠关系依据外,还需符合他国规定的正当法律程序原则。正当法律程序无意要求外国法院判决遵循与内国一致的诉讼程序,但从两大法系主要国家的立法和实践来看,正当法律程序有其共同的规则和内容,对此,我国立法应予借鉴和完善。

关键词(KeyWords)： 正当法律程序;;外国判决;;承认与执行;;立法完善

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation):

作者(Author): 王克玉;

Email:


参考文献(References)： [1]Yoav Oestreicher,the Rise and Fall of the“Mixed”and“Double”Convention Models Regarding Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Judgements,6Wash.U.Global Stud.L.Rev.2007.pp342-343.[2]Dicey&J.H.C.Morris,The Conflict of Laws,10th ed.1980,pp1037-38.[3]See Zaphiriou,tradional Recognition and Enforcement of Civil judgments,53Notre Dame L.Rev.1978p749.[1]Hilton v.Guyot,159U.S.(1895).[2]Marcia McCrory Ernst,Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Money Judgement in the United States and the United Kingdom in Light of Currency Conversion Problems,3Emory J.Int’l Disp.Resol.1988-1989,p66.[3]See Yoav Oestreicher,the Rise and Fall of the“Mixed”and“Double”Convention Models Regarding Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Judgements,6Wash.U.Global Stud.L.Rev.2007,p363.[4]Richards v.Williams[1905]11BCR122.[5]1928年的《国际私法公约》、1940年的《国际诉讼程序法条约》和1979年《关于外国判决与仲裁裁决的域外效力的公约》。[6]1932年北欧斯堪的纳维亚国家《关于相互承认和执行判决的哥本哈根公约》。[7]1958年阿拉伯国家间的《阿拉伯联盟关于执行判决的公约》。[8]1968年的《关于民商事司法管辖和判决执行公约》、欧共体国家与欧洲自由贸易联盟国家之间于1988年的《关于民、商事裁判管辖权和裁判执行的卢加诺公约》。[9]1971的《民商事外国判决的承认和执行公约》及其议定书、1973年《关于承认与执行扶养义务判决的公约》。10Article4(1)the judgment debtor,being the defendant in the originalproceeding did not receive notice of the original proceedings in suf-ficient time to defend and did not appear;or(2)the judgment was obtained by fraud.[1]§4(b)A foreign judgment need not be recognized if(1)the defendant in the proceedings in the foreign court did not re ceive notice of the proceedings in sufficient time to enable him to defend;(2)the judgment was obtained by fraud;[2]Glenn P.Hendrix,“International Judicial Assistance fromAmeirican Courts in Russian Litigation and Aibitration Proceedings”,the Rus-sian-Ameirican Symposium on Private International Law2004,p2.[3]Dierer Martiny,Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Money Judgments in the Federal Republic of Germany.35Am.J.Comp.L.1987p723.[4]同上,p742.[5]Masanori Takeda,Problems of Enforcing Child Support Orders Between the U.S.and Japan,琉大法学第74号(2005),第112页。[1]Takao Sawaki,“Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Judgment in Japan”,23Int’l L.1989,p32.[2]See Mother in Ohio,50Kominshu at319.[3]Yoav Oestreicher,the Rise and Fall of the“Mixed”and“Double”Convention Models Regarding Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Judgements,6Wash.U.Global Stud.L.Rev.2007,p366.[4]See Powell v.Cockburn,[1977]2S.C.R.218.[5]同上。[6]Masanori Takeda,Problems of Enforcing Child Support Orders Between the U.S.and Japan,琉大法学第74号(2005),第114页。[7]37Saiko Saibansho Keiji Hanreishu(Minshu)611,27Jail119.[8]Takao Sawaki,“Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Judgment in Japan”,23Int’l L.1989,p33.[1]See Cheshire and North,Private International Law,London Butterworths,1999,pp460-461.[2]See Society of Lloyd’s v.Meinzer,(2001),55O.R.(3d)704(C.A.).[3]Beals v.Saldanha,(2001),Carswell Ont2286(C.A.)[4]Tahan v.Hodgson,213U.S.App.D.C.306.[5]Bank of Iran v.Pahlavi,58F.3d1406(9th Cir.1995).[1]Dierer Martiny,Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Money Judgments in the Federal Republic of Germany.35Am.J.Comp.L.1987p741.[2]See Marcia McCrory Ernst,Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Money Judgement in the United States and the United Kingdom in Light of Currency Conversion Problems,3Emory J.Int’l Disp.Resol.1988-1989,p69.[1]李昌道编:《美国宪法史稿》,法律出版社1986年版。[2][日]木下太郎编:《九国宪法选介》,康树华译,群众出版社1981年版。[3]赵相林主编:《中国国际私法立法问题研究》,中国政法大学出版社2002年版。[4]许尚豪:“论民事诉讼程序属性的两面性”,载《社会科学家》2008年第1期。[5]陈瑞华:“程序正义的理论基础———评马修的尊严价值理论”,载《中国法学》2000年第3期。