何纳轮^1,2,
安伟^1,,,
杨敏^1,2
1. 中国科学院生态环境研究中心环境水质学国家重点实验室, 北京 100085;
2. 中国科学院大学, 北京 100049

作者简介: 何纳轮(1995-),男,硕士研究生,研究方向为环境风险评价,E-mail:hnl13@tsinghua.org.cn.

通讯作者: 安伟,anwei@rcees.ac.cn ;

基金项目: 国家自然科学基金资助项目（21976205）；水污染防治科技重大项目（2018ZX07502001）


中图分类号: X171.5

Study on the Cumulative Risk Assessment Method of Chemical Substances with U-Type Dose Response-Take Drinking Water Fluoride as Example

He Nalun^1,2,
An Wei^1,,,
Yang Min^1,2
1. State Key Laboratory of Environmental Aquatic Chemistry, Research Center for Eco-Environmental Sciences, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100085, China;
2. University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China

Corresponding author: An Wei,anwei@rcees.ac.cn ;

CLC number: X171.5

-->

摘要
HTML全文
图(0)表(0)
参考文献(60)
相关文章
施引文献
资源附件(0)
访问统计

摘要:人体对氟元素有U型剂量响应作用，低氟与高氟都会对人体健康产生影响，而饮用水是人体氟摄入的重要来源之一。本文建立了水氟浓度-龋齿患病率剂量效应曲线以及水氟浓度-氟斑牙患病率剂量效应曲线，从龋齿及氟斑牙这2种高发的疾病导致的伤残调整寿命年（DALYs）评价饮用水中氟元素浓度对人体健康的影响。结果表明，饮用水中氟元素浓度对人体影响呈U型曲线，对人体影响最低时的适宜浓度为0.75 mg·L^-1，对应的人均伤残调整寿命年为1.60×10^-6 DALYs per person-year（DALYs ppy）。我国重点城市自来水厂出水调查结果显示，平均氟浓度为0.287 mg·L^-1，范围为0.005~0.870 mg·L^-1。我国饮用水中氟元素对人体综合风险以伤残调整寿命年计约为1.80×10^-6 DALYs ppy，说明我国饮用水中氟元素对人体的风险处于低水平。
关键词: 氟/
龋齿病/
氟斑牙/
伤残调整寿命年/
U型曲线

Abstract:Human toxic response to fluorine was U-type, where low and high level of fluorine can cause harmful effect to health. Drinking water is one of the important sources of fluorine intake. In this study, the dose-response curves between fluorine concentration to the prevalence of dental caries and fluorosis were developed, and the disability adjusted life years (DALYs) was applied to assess the effects of fluoride in drinking water on human health. The results showed that the health effect of fluoride in drinking water was U-type shape, where the corresponding concentration of the lowest effect on human was about 0.75 mg·L^-1 with 1.60×10^-6 DALYs per person-year (DALYs ppy). In addition, fluoride concentrations were surveyed in drinking water plants of major cities in China, of which the average was 0.287 mg·L^-1 and range 0.005~0.870 mg·L^-1. The health risk of fluoride in drinking water of major cities of China was about 1.80×10^-6 DALYs ppy, which was at a low risk level.
Key words:fluorine/
dental caries/
dental fluorosis/
DALY/
U-type curve.

袁业畅, 何飞, 李燕, 等. 环境风险评价综述及案例讨论[J]. 环境科学与技术, 2013, 36(S1):455-463Yuan Y C, He F, Li Y, et al. A view of environmental risk assessment and the case discussion[J]. Environmental Science & Technology, 2013, 36(S1):455-463(in Chinese)

张小磊, 何宽, 马建华. 氟元素对人体健康的影响[J]. 微量元素与健康研究, 2006, 23(6):66-67Zhang X L, He K, Ma J H. Influence of fluorine on human health[J]. Studies of Trace Elements and Health, 2006, 23(6):66-67(in Chinese)

杨永建. 氟对人体健康的影响[J]. 中国科技信息, 2007(9):179-180

Lopez A D, Murray C C J L. The global burden of disease, 1990-2020[J]. Nature Medicine, 1998(11):1241-1243

陈媛, 熊传龙, 张琦, 等. 氟中毒暴露途径及健康效应研究进展[J]. 环境与健康杂志, 2016, 33(1):84-87Chen Y, Xiong C L, Zhang Q, et al. Multi-route fluoride exposure and health effects:A review of recent studies[J]. Journal of Environment and Health, 2016, 33(1):84-87(in Chinese)

刘永林, 马培, 雒昆利, 等. 1991-2012年中国地方性氟中毒病情动态变化[J]. 重庆师范大学学报:自然科学版, 2016, 33(2):142-151Liu Y L, Ma P, Luo K L, et al. The state and trend of endemic fluorosis from 1991 to 2012 in China[J]. Journal of Chongqing Normal University:Natural Science Edition, 2016, 33(2):142-151(in Chinese)

潘申龄, 安伟, 李红岩, 等. 饮水氟含量与龋齿率的剂量-效应关系的Meta回归分析[J]. 环境与健康杂志, 2013, 30(8):703-706Pan S L, An W, Li H Y, et al. Meta-regression on dose-response relationship of fluoride content in drinking water and dental caries rate[J]. Journal of Environment and Health, 2013, 30(8):703-706(in Chinese)

蔡玥, 伍晓玲, 薛明, 等. 恶性肿瘤疾病负担研究方法与进展[J]. 中国卫生信息管理杂志, 2015, 12(2):136-142Cai Y, Wu X L, Xue M, et al. The methodology review of cancer disease burden[J]. Chinese Journal of Health Informatics and Management, 2015, 12(2):136-142(in Chinese)

门阔. 儿童龋齿病的现状及防治建议[J]. 全科口腔医学电子杂志, 2018, 5(17):30-31

彭献镇, 王焕强, 韩静岭, 等. 中国中小学生龋齿患病率Meta分析[J]. 中国学校卫生, 2018, 39(10):1585-1588

中华人民共和国国家统计局. 中国统计年鉴2018[M]. 北京:中国统计出版社, 2018:64-78

曹采方. 对牙周病和龋齿患病率的思考——如何解读第三次全国口腔健康流行病学调查的资料[J]. 中华口腔医学杂志, 2013, 48(5):257-259

栗征. 《2017年我国卫生健康事业发展统计公报》出炉[J]. 中医药管理杂志, 2018, 26(12):205

Salomon J A, Haagsma J A, Davis A, et al. Disability weights for the Global Burden of Disease 2013 study[J]. Lancet Global Health, 2015, 3(11):e712-e723

郭晓芳, 张宏伟, 罗园园, 等. 中学生氟斑牙患者的社会心理因素调查分析[J]. 中国民康医学, 2009, 21(22):2895, 2940Guo X F, Zhang H W, Luo Y Y, et al. The study on the psychosocial factors of middle school students suffered from enamel fluorosis[J]. Medical Journal of Chinese People's Health, 2009, 21(22):2895, 2940(in Chinese)

余波, 银恭举, 张莉, 等. 饮水氟含量与儿童龋齿和氟斑牙关系的调查[J]. 中国地方病学杂志, 2003, 22(5):55-56Yu B, Yin G J, Zhang L, et al. Study on correlation between fluoride content in drinking-water and dental fluorosis and caries of children[J]. Chinese Journal of Endemiology, 2003, 22(5):55-56(in Chinese)

倪娜. 不同水氟含量地区8~12岁儿童氟斑牙和龋病患病情况调查[J]. 中国地方病防治杂志, 2018, 33(4):395

种戈香, 苗丰娥, 丛伟红, 等. 龋齿患病率与饮用水含氟量关系的调查[J]. 山东预防医学, 1996, 16(3):151

邓广赟, 安文谦. 氟含量对7-10岁学生氟牙症与龋齿的影响[J]. 河南预防医学杂志, 1999, 10(5):283-284

刘冬梅, 杨更森, 郭兰英, 等. 高氟区龋病与氟牙症流行特点[J]. 河北医科大学学报, 2003, 24(5):282-284Liu D M, Yang G S, Guo L Y, et al. Prevalence of dental caries and fluorosis in high-fluoride areas[J]. Journal of Hebei Medical University, 2003, 24(5):282-284(in Chinese)

江肖蔚. 缙云县儿童氟斑牙与龋齿患病情况调查[J]. 中国学校卫生, 2001, 22(3):229

黄少宏, 李梅, 欧尧, 等. 南海市两镇居民摄氟水平与龋病流行情况调查[J]. 华南预防医学, 2005, 31(3):36-38Huang S H, Li M,Ou Y, et al. Fluoride ingestion and caries prevalence among residents of two townships in Nanhai[J]. South China Journal of Preventive Medicine, 2005, 31(3):36-38(in Chinese)

林国恒, 蔡茂荣, 张尧堡. 漳州市饮水氟适宜浓度的流行病学调查[J]. 海峡预防医学杂志, 2001, 7(5):36-37Lin G H, Cai M R, Zhang Y B.The epidemiological survey on fitting fluorine concentration in drinking water in Zhangzhou City[J]. Strait Journal of Preventive Medicine, 2001, 7(5):36-37(in Chinese)

蒋正明. 饮水含氟量与氟斑牙关系的探讨[J]. 南京医科大学学报, 1997, 17(1):99

梁超轲, 王景占, 吴云鹏, 等. 饮水氟与人群龋齿关系的调查研究[J]. 环境与健康杂志, 1998, 15(2):51-54Liang C K, Wang J Z, Wu Y P, et al. Fluoride content in drinking water and human caries[J]. Journal of Environment and Health, 1998, 15(2):51-54(in Chinese)

苏红楼, 朱国伟, 张云华. 低氟区乳牙龋齿调查分析[J]. 中国学校卫生, 1995, 16(4):272

杨正焱, 郭志勇. 深圳市环境氟的水平及其对人体尿氟的影响[J]. 环境与健康杂志, 1993, 10(3):136

郝玉庆, 买买提·牙森, 王国荃, 等. 地方性氟中毒病区改水对中小学生龋患影响[J]. 中华地方病学杂志, 2000, 19(5):365-366Hao Y Q, Maimaiti Y, Wang G Q, et al. Influence of water improvement in endemic dental fluorosis area on caries in school boys and girls in Kuitun Xinjiang[J]. Chinese Journal of Endemiology, 2000, 19(5):365-366(in Chinese)

陈培忠, 云中杰, 高红旭, 等. 山东省3市城区水氟本底及学生牙齿状况调查分析[J]. 中国地方病防治杂志, 2004, 19(1):50-51Chen P Z, Yun Z J, Gao H X, et al. Investigation of fluoride basis and teeth's status of the students in 3 cities of Shandong Province[J]. Chinese Journal of Control of Endemic Diseases, 2004, 19(1):50-51(in Chinese)

庞瑞发, 张久涛. 地方性氟中毒病区改水对中小学生龋患影响[J]. 全科口腔医学电子杂志, 2016, 3(14):55, 57

周景林, 要路明, 崔启成. 饮水含氟量对儿童氟斑牙及龋齿影响的研究[J]. 现代预防医学, 1996, 23(1):58-60Zhou J L, Yao L M, Cui Q C. A study of the content of fluorine in drinking water and its influence on children's mottled teeth and dental caries[J]. Modern Preventive Medicine, 1996, 23(1):58-60(in Chinese)

马爱华, 李涛. 水氟与氟斑牙、龋齿患病率关系调查分析[J]. 数理医药学杂志, 1996, 9(3):53-54

王春江. 高青县地方性氟中毒病区少年儿童氟斑牙与龋齿患病情况调查[J]. 中国农村医学杂志, 2010, 8(2):51-53

朱伯相. 生活饮用水水氟与氟性牙病的调查研究[J]. 职业与健康, 2000, 16(2):37-38

汪旸, 王彩生, 向全永, 等. 饮水氟对儿童龋齿的影响[J]. 中国公共卫生, 2004, 20(5):530-531Wang Y, Wang C S, Xiang Q Y, et al. Effect of fluoride in drinking water on children's dental caries[J]. Chinese Journal of Public Health, 2004, 20(5):530-531(in Chinese)

黄广文, 袁碧涛, 杨正焱. 中小学生龋齿与氟的关系及其防治[J]. 中国公共卫生管理, 2004, 20(3):258-259

王连方, 张玲, 艾海提, 等. 新疆塔里木盆地维吾尔族儿童龋齿与氟关系分析[J]. 世界元素医学, 2004, 11(3):40-44Wang L F, Zhang L, Ai H T, et al. Analysis of relationship between dental caries and fluoride among Uygur children in Tarim basin of Xinjiang[J]. World Elemental Medicine, 2004, 11(3):40-44(in Chinese)

董璐, 陈伟, 姚培杰, 等. 西安市氟中毒病区水氟含量与儿童氟斑牙和龋齿的关系[J]. 中国学校卫生, 2018, 39(1):101-103Dong L, Chen W, Yao P J, et al. Relationship between fluorine concentration in drinking water and dental fluorosis, dental caries of children in endemic fluorosis area in Xi'an City[J]. Chinese Journal of School Health, 2018, 39(1):101-103(in Chinese)

李国薇, 牛犇. 饮用水氟含量及血清和尿液氟与龋齿和氟斑牙的相关性[J]. 中国卫生工程学, 2018, 17(3):362-363

英浩, 付承, 张玲, 等. 2004年阿勒泰地区饮用水氟含量与儿童氟斑牙流行现况调查[J]. 地方病通报, 2009, 24(6):59-60

赫娜, 吴蕊丽, 王玉春, 等. 2016年河北省衡水市辖区饮水型地方性氟中毒病情现状调查分析[J]. 医学动物防制, 2019, 35(4):391-393He N, Wu R L, Wang Y C, et al. Investigation and analysis of the status of drinking-water-type endemic fluorosis in Hengshui City of Hebei Province in 2016[J]. Journal of Medical Pest Control, 2019, 35(4):391-393(in Chinese)

何海, 王振礼, 徐赟. 2017年辽宁省本溪满族自治县地方性氟中毒防治效果分析[J]. 当代医学, 2019, 25(4):73-75He H, Wang Z L, Xu Y. Prevention and treatment of endemic fluorosis in Benxi Manchu Autonimous County, Liaoning Province in 2017[J]. Contemporary Medicine, 2019, 25(4):73-75(in Chinese)

王祥, 陆露, 马凤昌, 等. 蚌埠市水氟含量及8~12岁儿童氟斑牙患病情况[J]. 中国学校卫生, 2010, 31(5):586-587Wang X, Lu L, Ma F C, et al. Water fluorine content and prevalence of dental fluorosis among children aged 8-12 in Bengbu[J]. Chinese Journal of School Health, 2010, 31(5):586-587(in Chinese)

陈显赫, 张海涛, 杨德民. 防氟改水对儿童氟斑牙患病情况的影响[J]. 中国地方病防治杂志, 2016, 31(5):525

吴荣涛. 阜阳市饮水氟和儿童氟斑牙患病情况的现况调查[D]. 合肥:安徽医科大学, 2008:20-24 Wu R T. Survey on fluorine in the drinking-water and dental fluorosis of children in Fuyang City[D].Heifei:Anhui Medical University, 2008:20-24(in Chinese)

戴国钧, 张志瑜, 翟城, 等. 改水降氟预防小学生氟斑牙效果的调查[J]. 中国地方病学杂志, 1999(1):61

赵鲁明, 石晓蕾, 魏立梅. 高氟高碘饮水对潍坊地区农村学龄儿童氟斑牙病的影响[J]. 中国地方病防治杂志, 2016, 31(2):156-158Zhao L M, Shi X L, Wei L M. Effects of high fluoride and high iodine in drinking water on rural school-age children's dental fluorosis prevalence of XX area[J]. Chinese Journal of Control of Endemic Diseases, 2016, 31(2):156-158(in Chinese)

刘建臣. 高氟区氟斑牙与水氟及尿氟关系调查[J]. 中国学校卫生, 2001, 22(1):70

董建梅, 周晓梅, 吴同浩, 等. 连云港市降氟改水氟病区村8~12岁儿童氟斑牙调查分析[J]. 中国地方病防治杂志, 2011, 26(4):278-280Dong J M, Zhou X M, Wu T H, et al. An analysis of the incidence of dental fluorosis of children aged 8 to 12 years in endemic fluorosis villages that changed water in Lianyungang City[J]. Chinese Journal of Control of Endemic Diseases, 2011, 26(4):278-280(in Chinese)

刘晓莉, 李晓茜. 陕西省饮水型氟中毒防治效果调查[J]. 环境与健康杂志, 2009, 26(11):994-995Liu X L, Li X Q. Drinking water type fluorosis control and prevention in Shaanxi Province[J]. Journal of Environment and Health, 2009, 26(11):994-995(in Chinese)

许立凡, 徐火周, 陈少贤, 等. 汕头市饮水型高氟区改水后水氟含量与氟斑牙患病情况的流行病学调查与分析[J]. 中国农村卫生事业管理, 2004, 24(3):38-40Xu L F, Xu H Z, Chen S X, et al. Epidemiological survey and analysis of fluoride content in drinking water and dental fluorosis prevalence water-type high fluoride areas in Shantou City, Guangdong Province[J]. Chinese Rural Health Service Administration, 2004, 24(3):38-40(in Chinese)

姚培杰, 陈伟, 谢龙, 等. 西安市2005年疑似氟病区高氟水筛查及氟斑牙患病调查[J]. 职业与健康, 2008, 24(7):665-666Yao P J, Chen W, Xie L, et al. Investigation of the high-fluorine water screening and the incidence of dental fluorosis in the suspected high-fluorine areas in Xi'an City[J]. Occupation and Health, 2008, 24(7):665-666(in Chinese)

徐树旺, 徐志鑫. 小汤山镇地方性氟中毒病区8~12岁学生氟斑牙监测结果分析[J]. 中国地方病防治杂志, 2007, 22(6):436

张金玺, 邰锦英, 英占绵, 等. 新巴尔虎右旗水氟及儿童氟斑牙调查报告[J]. 内蒙古地方病防治研究, 1994, 19(3):107-109

李海燕. 饮水氟含量及尿氟、血清氟与氟斑牙患病率的相关性研究[J]. 中国卫生工程学, 2017, 16(4):512-513

张明访, 向全永, 彭芳, 等. 饮水氟含量与地方性氟中毒的剂量-反应关系[J]. 职业与健康, 2006, 22(8):566-568Zhang M F, Xiang Q Y, Peng F, et al. Study of the dose-response relationship between fluoride concentration in drinking water and endemic fluorosis[J]. Occupation and Health, 2006, 22(8):566-568(in Chinese)

宋代琴, 周云平, 刘靖靖, 等. 淄博市2017年水氟水平与儿童氟斑牙监测结果分析[J]. 中国学校卫生, 2018, 39(10):1553-1555

王凌卿. 儿童龋齿的发病原因分析及其预防措施[J]. 医学理论与实践, 2014, 27(23):152-153

候鹏飞, 舒为群. 饮用水氟浓度与儿童健康的剂量效应关系[J]. 职业与健康, 2017, 33(9):1289-1293Hou P F, Shu W Q. Dose-effect relationship between children's health and fluoride concentration in drinking water[J]. Occupation and Health, 2017, 33(9):1289-1293(in Chinese)

张莉, 余波, 朱新波, 等. 氟斑牙患病率和流行指数与水氟尿氟的多元线性分析[J]. 中国地方病学杂志, 2004, 23(2):77-78Zhang L, Yu B, Zhu X B, et al. Multiple linear regression of the rate and index of dental fluorosis and fluoride content in drinking-water and urine[J]. Chinese Journal of Endemiology, 2004, 23(2):77-78(in Chinese)