¶ñÕ®ÔÚ¹ú¼Ê·¨ÖеijÁµíÓ뷴˼¡ª¡ªÒÔÖйúµÄº£ÍâͶ×Ê·çÏÕΪÊÓãÐ
ÍõÊçÃô; 1:´óÁ¬º£Ê´óѧ¹ú¼Êº£Ê·¨ÂÉÑо¿ÖÐÐÄ ÕªÒª(Abstract)£º

ÔÚÀúÊ·µÄ¾íàùÖÐ̽ѰÕæʵµÄ¶ñÕ®,½åÒÔÓ¡Ö¤Öйúº£ÍâͶ×ʵĺϷ¨ÓëÊʸñ¡£¾¡¹Ü"¶ñÕ®²»Óè¼Ì³Ð"µÄ¹ú¼Ê·¨Ê¹ÃüÓдýÌáÉý,µ«Æä¶ÔÓÚº£ÍâͶ×ʵĸºÃæÓ°ÏìͬÑù²»ÈÝíþÊÓ¡£¶ñÕ®Ó뺣ÍâͶ×ʱ£ÏÕÖ®¼ä¼ÈÓÐÇ£Á¬ÐÔ¡¢Ó־߶ÀÁ¢ÐÔ,ÕýÃæ½â¶ÁÁ½ÕßÖ®¼ä´í×Û¸´ÔӵĹØϵ,ÊDZÜÃâÀûÒæØü¹Ø·½Öص¸¸²ÕÞµÄÁ¼²ß¡£½ø¶øÑ°Çóº£ÍâͶ×ÊÕþÖηçÏÕµÄÆÀ¹À»úÖÆ,˳Àí³ÉÕµسÉΪÖйúÕþ¸®ÍöÑò²¹ÀεĴëÊ©¡£

¹Ø¼ü´Ê(KeyWords)£º ¶ñÕ®;;¡°¶ñÕ®²»Óè¼Ì³Ð¡±;;º£ÍâͶ×Ê·çÏÕ

Abstract:

Keywords:

»ù½ðÏîÄ¿(Foundation):

×÷Õß(Author): ÍõÊçÃô;

Email:


²Î¿¼ÎÄÏ×(References)£º [1]Sarah Ludington&Mitu Gulati,A Convenient Untruth:Fact and Fantasy in the Doctrine of Odious Debts,Virginia Journal Of Interna-tional Law,Vol.482008,p.595-639.[2]A.N.Sack,Les effets de transformations des¦Itats sur leur dettes publiques et autres obligations financi¨¨res,(Paris:Recueil Sirey,1927).[3]ͬÉÏ,µÚ52Ò³¡£[4]ͬÉÏ,µÚ68Ò³¡£[5]Seth Michael Reynolds,Odious Debt:Modernizing Ancient Problems,available at http://works.bepress.com/seth_reynolds/1ÒÀÕÕ¡¶¹ú¼Ê·¨Ôº¹æÔ¼¡·µÚ38Ìõ(ËÄ)¹æ¶¨,¡°ÔÚµÚ59Ìõ¹æ¶¨Ö®ÏÂ,˾·¨ÅÐÀý¼°¸÷¹úȨÍþ×î¸ßÖ®¹«·¨¼Òѧ˵,×÷Ϊȷ¶¨·¨ÂÉÔ­ÔòÖ®²¹Öú×ÊÁÏÕß¡±¡£[6]E.Feilchenfeld,Public Debts and State Succession,New York:Macmillan,1931,pp.450-860.[7]D.P.O'Connell,State Succession in Municipal and International Law Vol.I,Cambridge:C.U.P,1967,pp.458-461.[8]J.Foorman&M.Jehle,Effects of State and Government Succession on Commercial Bank Loans to Foreign Sovereign Borrowers(1982)Ill.L.R.9,p.21-25.[9]G.Frankenberg&R.Kneiper,Legal Problems of theOver indebtedness of Developing Countries:TheCurrent Relevanceof theDoctrineof Odious Debts,Industrial Bank of Kuwait(1984),p.415.[1]D.P.O'Connell,State Succession in Municipal and International Law Vol.I(Cambridge:C.U.P,1967),pvi.[2]Seema Jayachandran&Michael Kremer,Odious Debt,96AM.ECON.REV.82(2006).[3]Sarah Ludington&Mitu Gulati,A Convenient Untruth:Fact and Fantasy in the Doctrine of Odious Debts,Virginia Journal Of International Law,Vol.482008,p.597.[4]Ashfaq Khalfan,Jeff King,Bryan Thomas,Advancing the Odious Debt Doctrine,available at http://www.cisdl.org/pdf/debtentire.pdf.p.43.[5]C.C.Hyde,International Law Chiefly as Interpreted and Applied in the United States2nd.Ed.,(Boston:Little Brown,1945)at400ff(cited by G.Frankenberg&R.Kneiper,"Legal Problems of the Overindebtedness of Developing Countries:The Current Relevance of the Doc-trine of Odious Debts",(1984)12Int'l J.of the Sociology of Law415,p.428).[6]D.P.O'Connell,State Succession in Municipal and International Law,Vol.I(Cambridge:C.U.P,1967),p.458-462.J.Foorman&M.Jehle,Effects of State and Government Succession on Commercial Bank Loans to Foreign Sovereign Borrowers,(1982)Ill.L.R.9,p.21-25.P.Wood,The Law and Practice of International Finance(London:Sweet&Maxwell,1980),p.120-121.[7]µÚ¶þ´Î²¼¶ûÕ½Õù·¢ÉúÓÚ1899Äê10ÔÂ11ÈÕÖÁ1902Äê5ÔÂ31ÈÕÆÚ¼ä,Ö¸Ó¢¹úÓëµÂÀ¼Ê¿Íß¹²ºÍ¹úºÍ°ÂÀ¼ÖÎ×ÔÓÉ°îÖ®¼äµÄÕ½Õù¡£Õ½Õù½áÊøºó,¶ÀÁ¢µÄµÂÀ¼Ê¿ÍߺͰÂÀ¼Öιú¼ÒÃðÍö,ÄϷDz¼¶ûÈËÈ«²¿ÂÙΪӢ¹úµÄ³¼Ãñ¡£[8]Altvater,E.,et al.,eds,The Poverty of Nations:A Guide to the Debt Crisis-From Argentina to Zaire,(New Jersey:Zed Books,1991).p.160.[9]L¨¦once Ndikumana and James K.Boyce,Measurement of Capital Flight:Methodology and Results for Sub-Saharan African Countries,African Development Review,Volume22,Issue4,December2010,p.147.[10]Ashfaq Khalfan,Jeff King,Bryan Thomas,Advancing the Odious Debt Doctrine,available at http://www.cisdl.org/pdf/debtentire.pdf,p.9.[1]Y.Makkonen,International Law and the New States of Africa(Paris:Ethiopian National Agency for UNESCO,1983),p.375,citing D.P.O'Connell,State Succession in Municipal and International Law,Vol.I(Cambridge:C.U.P,1967),p.431(Israel),444(Guinea),472(Indonesia and Algeria).See also K.Zemanek,State Succession after Decolonization,(1965)116Recueil des Cours of the Hague Academy of International Law.[2]Ian Brownlie,Principles of Public International Law,5th ed.(Oxford:Oxford University Press,1998),pp.11-12.[3]P.Wood,The Law and Practice of International Finance(London:Sweet&Maxwell,1980),pp.120-21.[4]E.G.Schaffer&R.I.Snyder,Contemporary Practice of Public International Law,(Dobbs Ferry:Oceana Publications,1997),pp.123-124.[5]P.Adams,Odious Debts,Loose Lending,Corruption and the Third World's Environmental Legacy,(London:Earthscan,1991),p.77.[6]E.Feilchenfeld,Public Debts and State Succession,(New York:Macmillan,1931),p.701,p.714.[7]ͬÉÏ,µÚ701Ò³¡£[8]Sarah Ludington&G.Mitu Gulati,A Convenient Untruth:Fact and Fantasy in the Doctrine of Odious Debts,Virginia Journal Of Interna-tional Law,Vol.482008,p.599.[9]Buckley,R.,Emerging Markets Debt:An Analysis of the Secondary Market,(Boston:Kluwer Law International,1999),p.8[10]Seth Reynolds,Odious Debt:Modernizing Ancient Problems,available at http://works.bepress.com/seth_reynolds.[1]Lee C.Buchheit,G.Mitu Gulati and Robert B.Thompson,The Dilemma of Odious Debts,56DUKE L.J.1201,1202(March2007).See also Sarah Ludington,G.Mitu Gulati and Alfred L.Brophy,Applied Legal History:Demystifying the Doctrine of Odious Debt,11Theoretical Inquiries IN L,p.159-160(2008).[2]¹ùÎľ²:¡°Àû±ÈÑÇ·´¶ÔÅɳƻ¶Ó­ÖйúÆóÒµÖØ»ØÀû±ÈÑÇ¡±,http://world.huanqiu.com/roll/2011-08/1922232.html.×îºó·ÃÎÊÈÕÆÚ:2011-09-03.[3]ÓÚÃË¡¢Õź­:¡°Å·Ã˼ƻ®¼Ó´ó¶ÔÐðÖƲÃÖÐ×ÊÆóÒµ×ÅÊÖÓ¦¶Ô×¼±¸¡±,ÔØ¡¶21ÊÀ¼Í¾­¼Ã±¨µÀ¡·http://www.21cbh.com/,×îºó·ÃÎÊÈÕÆÚ:2011-12-02.[4]¡°¹Û²ì:Öйúº£ÍâͶ×ÊÓëÊÀ½ç¿ç¾³Í¶×ÊÌصã³öÏÖÈý·½ÃæµÄ±³À롱,http://topic.ec.com.cn/topic/zhongguoqiye/index.shtml,×îºó·ÃÎÊÈÕÆÚ:2011-09-21.[5]A.N.Sack,Les effets de transformations des¨¦tats sur leur dettes publiques et autres obligations financi¨¨res,(Paris:Recueil Sirey,1927),p.158.[6]Ashfaq Khalfan,Jeff King,Bryan Thomas,Advancing the Odious Debt Doctrine,available at http://www.cisdl.org/pdf/debtentire.pdf,p.32.[1]D.P.O'Connell,State Succession in Municipal and International Law,Vol.I(Cambridge:C.U.P,1967),p.460.[2]Ashfaq Khalfan,Jeff King,Bryan Thomas.Advancing the Odious Debt Doctrine,available at http://www.cisdl.org/pdf/debtentire.pdf,p.12.[3]A.N.Sack,Les effets de transformations destats sur leur dettes publiques et autres obligations financi¨¨res,(Paris:Recueil Sirey,1929),p.157.[4]E.Feilchenfeld,Public Debts and State Succession(New York:Macmillan,1931),pp.701-714.[5]E.Feilchenfeld,Public Debts and State Succession(New York:Macmillan,1931)at450ff.and860ff,pp.704-705.[6]Ashfaq Khalfan,Jeff King,Bryan Thomas,Advancing the Odious Debt Doctrine,available at http://www.cisdl.org/pdf/debtentire.pdf,p.43.[7]Supra note,p.44.[8]Vilas v.City of Manila,220US(1911),p.355.[1]J.F.O'Connor,Good Faith in International Law(Brookfield,Vermont:Dartmouth,1991),p.40.[2]D.P.O'Connell,State Succession in Municipal and International Law Vol.I(Cambridge:C.U.P,1967),p.34.[3]supra note p.266.[4]C.H.Schreuer,Unjustified Enrichment in International Law,(1974)22A.J.Comp.L.281,p.294.[5]Ò¦¹ð÷:¡°ÖйúºÍÀû±ÈÑÇδǩ¶©Ë«±ßͶ×ʱ£»¤Ð­¶¨¡±,ÖйúÍøchina.com.cn2011-04-20,×îºó·ÃÎÊÈÕÆÚ:2011-12-02.[6]M.Whiteman,Digest of International Law,vol.5(Washington,D.C.:Government Printing Office,1965),pp.224-230;A.Kiss,¡®Abuse of Rights¡¯in R.Bernhardt,ed.,Encyclopedia of Public International Law,vol.1(Amsterdam:North-Holland,1992),p.4-8.[7](Greece,United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland)(1956),12R.I.A.A.83,p.94(Commission of Arbitration,Arbitra-tors:R.J.Alfaro et al).Greece argued that the withholding of evidence by the British government in national court proceedings in England consti-tuted¡°an abuse of right which amounted to a denial of justice.¡±[8]Case Concerning Application of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide(Provisional Measures),Or-der of13September1993,[1993]I.C.J.Rep.325,p.19.The Federal Republic of Yugoslavia argued that Bosnia-Herzegovina's request for pro-visional measures constituted an abuse of rights.[1]D.P.O'Connell,State Succession in Municipal and International Law Vol.I(Cambridge:C.U.P,1967),pp.458-461.[2]Ian Brownlie,Principles of Public International Law,5th ed.(Oxford:Oxford University Press,1998),pp.11-12.[3]Ian Brownlie,Principles of Public International Law,5th ed.(Oxford:Oxford University Press,1998),pp.457-458.[4]´÷«h±àÒë:¡°º£ÍâͶ×ÊÖжíÆóÒµ»ß¸ÐÐΪ×î³£¼û¡±,¡¶Å·ÖÞʱ±¨Íø¡·http://www.oushinet.com/172-4427-148346.xhtml,×îºó·ÃÎÊÈÕÆÚ:2011-12-03.[1]Asia and the Pacific,available at http://www.miga.org/projects/index.cfm-stid=1529&country_id=47&hcountrycode=CN.[2]Commission on Human Rights,Joint Report by the Independent Expert on Structural Adjustment Programmes and the Special Rapporteur on ForeignDebt,UN ESCOR,2000,UN Doc.E/CN.4/2000/51,p.40[3]A Jubilee Call for Debt Cancellation and Economic Justice,Rome,17November,1998(First Jubilee2000International Conference)and Call to the G7Leaders:Declaration of Jubilee2000movements,21July,2000(Okinawa International Jubilee Conference),cited in Canadian Ecumenical Jubilee Initiative,Policy Forum,Illegitimate Debt:Definitions and Strategies for Repudiation and Cancellation,(Sheraton Hall,Wyc-liffe College,Toronto,15-16November,2000)[unpublished],p.21.[4]In relation to Canada's last report,see Toronto Star,Canada faces U.N.Scrutiny:Committee wants Explanation on Social ConditionsSep-tember28,1998,Toronto Star,Canada branded as¡®inhumane¡¯U.N.committee says workfare violates treaty November27,1998,Calgary Sun,U.N.Fails Canada on Social Front,December5,1998,Toronto Star,U.N.Committee Finds us Lacking,December8,1998.Some reactions were negative,Financial Post,Editorial:No Apologies on Human Rights,December2,1998.[1]Committee on Economic,Social and Cultural Rights.General Comment No.2(1990),UN Doc.E/1990/23,p.10.[2]P.Alston&G.Quinn,The Nature and Scope of States Parties'Obligations under the International Covenant on Economic,Social and Cul-tural Rights,(1987)9Hum.Rts.Q.156,p.188-190.[3]Committee on Economic,Social and Cultural Rights,Poverty and the International Covenant on Economic,Social and Cultural Rights,UN ESCOR,2001,UN Doc.E/C.12/2001/10,p.21.Debt repayments have at times amounted to between69%to200%of their combined health,education and social expenditure,as has been the case of Zambia,as stated in Commission on Human Rights,Joint Report by the Independent Expert on Structural Adjustment Programmes and the Special Rapporteur on Foreign Debt,UN ESCOR,2000,UN Doc.E/CN.4/2000/51,p.17.[4]P.Wood,The Law and Practice of International Finance(London:Sweet&Maxwell,1980),p.51.[5]J.Hurlock,The Way Ahead for Sovereign Debt(1995)International Financial Law Review[July1995]11,p.11.[6]Tsikata,Sovereign Borrowers,Foreign Creditors and the Resolution of Sovereign Insolvency:A Legal Appraisal of Contemporary Practise,Thesis submitted for the University of Toronto,1993[unpublished:on file with the National Library of Canada],p.92.[7]P.Wood,The Law and Practice of International Finance(London:Sweet&Maxwell,1980),p.46.[8]V.Carrillo-Batalla Lucas,Conflicts of Laws in International Lending Transactions-Governing Law and Choice of Forum in D.Carreau&M.Shaw eds.The External Debt/La dette ext¨¦rieure(Dordrecht:Martinus Nijhoff,1995),p.454.[9]R.MacMillan,The New Latin American Debt Regime:Towards a Sovereign Debt Work-out System,(1995)16J.Intl.L.Bus.57,p.72.[1]P.Wood,The Law and Practice of International Finance(London:Sweet&Maxwell,1980),p.53.[2]Buchheit&Jeremiah Pam,The Pari Passu Clause in Sovereign Debt Instruments,53EMORY L.J,p.869,872-877(2004)and Wil-liam Bratton,Pari Passu and a Distressed Sovereign's Rational Choices,53EMORY L.J.823,p.825-827(2004).[3]Jonathan Shafter,The Due Diligence Model:A New Approach to the Problem of Odious Debts,Ethics&International Affairs,Volume21,Issue1,March2007,p.58-59.[1]³ÂºÀ¡¢³Â»»ÁÖ:¡°ÂÛ¶ñÕ®²»Óè¼Ì³ÐÔ­Ôò¡±,ÔØ¡¶½ñÈղƸ»¡·2010ÄêµÚ3ÆÚ¡£[2]ÕÅÕð:¡°ÒÁÀ­¿ËÕ½Õù¶ÔÖйú¾­¼ÃµÄÓ°Ï족,ÔØ¡¶ÏÖ´ú¾­¼Ã̽ÌÖ¡·2003ÄêµÚ6ÆÚ¡£[3]¹Ë°²°²¡¢µËÃ÷Óî:¡°ÖÐÆóÔÚÀû±ÈÑÇËðʧһÀÀ¡±,ÔØ¡¶Ïã¸ÛÉ̱¨¡·2011Äê3ÔÂ29ÈÕ¡£[4]´ÞÆô±ó:¡°ÖйúÆóÒµÔÚÀû±ÈÑÇÊÜËð200ÒÚÃÀÔª±£ÏÕÅ⸶²»×ã4ÒÚÔª¡±,ÔØ¡¶±±¾©É̱¨¡·2011Äê04ÔÂ25ÈÕ¡£[5]ÂíÐÂÃñ:¡°ÁªºÏ¹ú¹ú¼Ò¼°Æä²Æ²ú¹ÜϽ»íÃ⹫ԼÆÀ½é¡±,ÔØ¡¶·¨Ñ§¼Ò¡·2005ÄêµÚ6ÆÚ¡£